Ad Sabinum libri
Ex libro XI
Dig. 13,6,13Pomponius libro undecimo ad Sabinum. Is qui commodatum accepit si non apparentis rei nomine commodati condemnetur, cavendum ei est, ut repertam dominus ei praestet. 1Si quem quaestum fecit is qui experiendum quid accepit, veluti si iumenta fuerint eaque locata sint, id ipsum praestabit qui experiundum dedit: neque enim ante eam rem quaestui cuique esse oportet, priusquam periculo eius sit. 2Si libero homini, qui mihi bona fide serviebat, quasi servo rem commodavero, videamus, an habeam commodati actionem. nam et Celsus filius aiebat, si iussissem eum aliquid facere, vel mandati cum eo vel praescriptis verbis experiri me posse: idem ergo et in commodato erit dicendum. nec obstat, quod non hac mente cum eo, qui liber bona fide nobis serviret, contraheremus quasi eum obligatum habituri: plerumque enim id accidit, ut extra id quod ageretur tacita obligatio nascatur, veluti cum per errorem indebitum solvendi causa datur.
Pomponius, On Sabinus, Book XI. Where a person who received a loan has judgment rendered against him in an action on loan, on the ground that the property had disappeared; security must be furnished him that if the owner finds it, he will deliver it to him. 1Where a party receives something for the purpose of trying it, as, for instance, beasts of burden, and they are hired out by him, and he profits by this use; he must refund the actual amount which he obtained to him who let him have the animals on trial; for no one should be allowed to profit by anything before it is held at his risk. 2Where I lend an article to a free man who has been serving me in good faith as a slave, let us see whether I am entitled to an action on loan against him. Celsus, the son, says that if I had ordered him to do anything, I could proceed against him either by an action on mandate, or by an action for the construction of the contract, and therefore the same rule should apply in the case of a loan. It makes no difference whether, if we contract with a freeman who is serving us in good faith as a slave, we do not do so intending to place him under an obligation, for it frequently happens that a tacit obligation arises in addition to what is intended at the time; as, for instance, where money which is not due is paid by mistake for the purpose of discharging a debt.
Dig. 21,2,27Pomponius libro undecimo ad Sabinum. Hoc iure utimur, ut exceptiones ex persona emptoris obiectae si obstant, venditor ei non teneatur, si vero ad personam venditoris respicient, contra: certe nec ex empto nec ex stipulatione duplae nec simplae actio competit emptori, si exceptio ei ex facto ipsius opposita obstiterit.
Pomponius, On Sabinus, Book XI. We adopt the rule that where exceptions are interposed against the purchaser, and they prevail, the vendor will not be liable; but where they have reference to the act of the vendor, the contrary rule applies. For it is certain that the purchaser will have no right to an action either on purchase, or under the stipulation for double, or even simple damages, where an exception based on his own act is successfully pleaded.
Dig. 21,2,29Pomponius libro undecimo ad Sabinum. Si rem, quam mihi alienam vendideras, a domino redemerim, falsum esse quod Nerva respondisset posse te a me pretium consequi ex vendito agentem, quasi habere mihi rem liceret, Celsus filius aiebat, quia nec bonae fidei conveniret et ego ex alia causa rem haberem. 1Si duplae stipulator ex possessore petitor factus et victus sit, quam rem si possideret retinere potuerit, petiaaDie Großausgabe fügt ita ein. autem utiliter non poterit, vel ipso iure promissor duplae tutus erit vel certe doli mali exceptione se tueri poterit, sed ita, si culpa vel sponte duplae stipulatoris possessio amissa fuerit. 2Quolibet tempore venditori renuntiari potest, ut de ea re agenda adsit, quia non praefinitur certum tempus in ea stipulatione, dum tamen ne prope ipsam condemnationem id fiat.
Pomponius, On Sabinus, Book XI. If you should sell me property belonging to another, and I should repurchase it from the true owner; Celsus, the son, says that the opinion of Nerva is not correct; namely, that you, in bringing an action on sale, can recover the price from me; because I was, as it were, entitled to the property, since it is not agreeable to good faith that I should hold property under a title belonging to someone else. 1Where a stipulator for double damages instead of being the possessor becomes the claimant and loses his case, if he had been in possession of the property he could have retained it, but he cannot legally bring suit to recover it, as the promisor of double damages will be secure by operation of law, or he can undoubtedly protect himself by an exception on the ground of fraud. This, however, is the case only where possession was lost through the negligence, or with the consent of the stipulator for double damages. 2The vendor can be notified to appear at any time whatsoever when the matter is brought up in court, because a certain date is not fixed by this stipulation; provided, however, this is not done before the time that judgment is rendered.
Dig. 41,1,21Pomponius libro undecimo ad Sabinum. Si servus meus tibi bona fide serviret et rem emisset traditaque ei esset, Proculus nec meam fieri, quia servum non possideam, nec tuam, si non ex re tua sit parata. sed si liber bona fide tibi serviens emerit, ipsius fieri. 1Si rem meam possideas et eam velim tuam esse, fiet tua, quamvis possessio apud me non fuerit.
Pomponius, On Sabinus, Book XI. If my slave is serving you in good faith, and he purchases something which is delivered to him, Proculus says that it will not become mine, because I have not the slave in my possession; nor will it be yours, because it was not acquired by means of your property. If, however, a freeman buys anything while he is serving you as a slave, it will belong to him individually. 1If you are in possession of property belonging to me, and I wish it to be yours, it will become yours, even though it may not have come into my hands.
Dig. 50,17,25Pomponius libro undecimo ad Sabinum. Plus cautionis in re est quam in persona.
Pomponius, On Sabinus, Book XI. Real is better than personal security.